World Mizrachi Weekly Parsha Newsletter
Back to the Weekly Parsha Newsletter List
ToldotPublished: 27/Nov/08 |
Parshat Toldot
Being Careful to Keep it True
Rabbi Yossef Carmel, Eretz Hemdah
This week’s haftara relates to Hashem’s outlook on the ongoing rivalry between Yaakov and Eisav: " ‘I loved you,’ said Hashem, and you asked, ‘In what way did you love us?’ ‘Is Eisav not a brother of Yaakov? I loved Yaakov and Eisav I hated ...’" (Malachi 1:2-3).
We grapple with the question of whether Yaakov was justified in taking drastic steps to obtain such prominence. The midrash says that he was "forced, bent over, and crying" (Sechel Tov, Bereishit 27). Yitzchak certainly did not seem to portray Yaakov’s actions favorably, saying: "Your brother came b’mirmah (with deceipt) and took your blessing" (Bereishit 27:35). Chazal and most commentaries tried to explain Yitzchak’s apparently harsh words in a more positive light. After all the answers and explanations, the problem persisted within the nation: how do we reconcile the importance of maintaining truthfulness with our patriarch’s behavior?
The following moving p’sukim end off our haftara. "My covenant was with him, the life and the peace. I gave these to him that he should fear me, and He feared Me, and before My Name he lowered himself. A Torah of truth was in his mouth, and iniquity was not found in his lips. In peace and a straight path he went with Me, and he brought back many from sin. For the lips of a kohen guard wisdom, and they shall ask Torah from his lips, for he is an angel of Hashem" (Malachi 2:5-7). What is the Torah of truth (torat emet), which is at the heart of this special person? Recall also that this phrase is at the heart of the beracha on the Torah after an aliyah. Ibn Ezra says that it means that one does not take bribes. Radak says that one does not say one thing and mean another. Two midrashim relate it to things one hears from his teacher. The Yerushalmi (Pe’ah 1:1) says that even those need to be true, whereas Bereishit Rabba (1) says that what one hears from his teacher is torat emet. What is the basis of their disagreement?
According to Bereishit Rabba, that which one learns form his teacher is the most reliable. The Yerushalmi posits that even those things need to pass through a "strainer of truth." If one is not sure about it, he shouldn’t teach it to his own students. In fact, halachic midrash learns the following from the pasuk: "He did not make the pure impure or make the impure pure" (Sifra, Shemini 1). In other words, a Torah of truth is such that one is as careful not to forbid the permitted as not to permit the forbidden. The requirements of torat emet apply even to one who has positive intentions in being stringent. Instituting stringencies requires satisfaction of the following conditions: 1) one says openly that it is done to distance one from possible sin; 2) it is not a double stringency; 3) it is a formal rabbinic institution and not merely a minhag. Anything but this is not torat emet.
Let us remember this when we rule for the public or even for our students, even if we have good intentions for ruling otherwise.
News & Events
COMING SOON – Halacha Yomit program
OUR LATEST PROGRAM – Coming soon – Chanukah 5769 – World Mizrachi's Halacha Yomit program. Join us in this worldwide learning initiative… watch this space for more details…
UPDATE - World Mizrachi Heritage Tour #8 – India
Due to high demand and a waiting list, we are investigating the option of a second bus. To register your interest, email daniel@worldmizrachi.org NOW!!
Mumbai – Rajastan – Agra – Delhi; 9-19 February 2009. To see the program, visit our website - www.mizrachi.org .
Personals
Please advise us of all good news and sad news that you care to share with others, else we cannot post it – email mizrachi@worldmizrachi.org .
Refuah Sheleimah– World Mizrachi wishes a Refuah Sheleimah to Rabbi Mordechai Eliyahu Shlita, Mordechai Tzemach Ben Mazal Tov (Former Chief Rabbi of Israel.)
Refuah Sheleimah– World Mizrachi wishes a Refuah Sheleimah to Myron Sokal, Meir Menachem ben Blima.
Refuah Sheleimah– World Mizrachi wishes a Refuah Sheleimah to Jerry Rosenfeld.
Israelat 60 Greeting Cards
World Mizrachi are proud to offer 6 blank greeting cards on the occasion of Israel at 60 to send to others to increase the awareness of this monumental occasion. To order sets email mizrachi@worldmizrachi.org
Sefer Torah Dedication
World Mizrachi is writing a Sefer Torah to honor its long-time World Chairman Mr. Kurt Rothschild, who has dedicated his life to Eretz Yisrael, Am Yisrael & Torat Yisrael. We invite you to join us in this endeavor. Full details available at: www.mizrachi.org
Book of the Month
From the Book of the Month club – proudly brought to you by World Mizrachi & Urim Publications:
For the Love of Israel and the Jewish People: Essays and Studies on Israel, Jews and Judaism: http://www.urimpublications.com/Merchant2/merchant.mv?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=UP&Product_Code=LoveOfIsrael&Category_Code=aaa
Covenantal Imperatives: Essays by Walter S Wurzburger on Jewish Law, Thought and Community:
